A methodological framework for exploring SME finance with SAFE data

Research on small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) access to bank finance is vital for the euro area economy. SMEs heavily represent the European business sector, employing around 100 million people and accounting for more than half of the Gross Domestic Product. Research studies in the field often rely on the ECB/EC Survey on the Access to Finance of Enterprises (SAFE). Many studies employ probit or logit models with categorical dependent variables derived from SAFE. The research findings show that hardly any study employs the simpler linear probability model (LPM), with a dominant lack of research providing evidence that justifies the model selection process and suitability. However, it is well known that different econometrics models can lack consistency and frequently yield different results. Yet, the literature has no consensus on the best econometric approach. In addition, there is a lack of robustness tests in the literature to ensure model validity, underlining the need for a comprehensive review of the methodological framework that dominates SAFE data use. This paper addresses the identified research gap by introducing a robust methodological framework that helps researchers identify and choose an appropriate categorical model when using SAFE data. The study adds significant value to the extant literature by identifying four criteria that need to be considered when selecting the appropriate model among three common binary dependent models: LPM, probit and logit models. The findings show that the probit model was appropriate is all cases but that the LPM should not be disregarded, as it can be used in two cases: when considering the interaction between monetary policy and debt to assets and monetary policy and innovation. The use of the LPM is justified as a less complex econometric model, allowing for clearer communication of the results. This innovative, robust approach to choosing the appropriate econometric categorical dependent model when employing SAFE data contributes to support policy effectively.