Bayesian analysis of stochastic volatility models with mixture-of-normal distributions

Stochastic volatility (SV) models usually assume that the distribution of asset returns conditional on the latent volatility is normal. This article analyzes SV models with a mixture-of-normal distributions in order to compare with other heavy-tailed distributions such as the Student-t distribution and generalized error distribution (GED). A Bayesian method via Markov-chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) techniques is used to estimate parameters and Bayes factors are calculated to compare the fit of distributions. The method is illustrated by analyzing daily data from the Yen/Dollar exchange rate and the Tokyo stock price index (TOPIX). According to Bayes factors, we find that while the t distribution fits the TOPIX better than the normal, the GED and the normal mixture, the mixture-of-normal distributions give a better fit to the Yen/Dollar exchange rate than other models. The effects of the specification of error distributions on the Bayesian confidence intervals of future returns are also examined. Comparison of SV with GARCH models shows that there are cases that the SV model with the normal distribution is less effective to capture leptokurtosis than the GARCH with heavy-tailed distributions.