IDEAS home Printed from https://ideas.repec.org/p/akf/cafewp/41.html

A Tale of Two Outcomes: Non-audit Services and Auditor Independence After the EU Audit Directive and Regulation (EU ADR)

Author

Listed:
  • Holmes, Mark

Abstract

This study evaluates whether the EU’s Audit Directive and Regulation (EU ADR) changed the relationship between auditor provided non-audit services (NAS) and auditor independence in the UK. While NAS can create economic bonding that suppresses negative reporting, it may also generate knowledge spillovers that improve the auditor’s client-specific knowledge and reporting quality. Using UK-listed, UK-headquartered non-financial firms from 2010-2020, we examine whether EU ADR implementation moderated NAS-related economic incentives across two reporting thresholds; qualified opinions and going-concern comments. Our study finds no evidence that NAS is associated with audit qualifications, nor that EU ADR changed this relationship. In contrast, we document a significant post-EU ADR shift in the NAS-going-concern comment relationship. Prior to the EU ADR, higher NAS was associated with a lower likelihood of going-concern comments; after implementation this negative association is significantly attenuated, that is consistent with reduced economic bonding in discretionary reporting. Similarly, probability-scale effects indicate economically meaningful changes in going-concern comment behaviour, while high-threshold, qualification decisions, remain largely unchanged. Results are robust to alternative specifications and audit firm heterogeneity. Overall, engagement-level NAS restrictions appear to matter primarily where auditors retain reporting discretion, informing debates on structural reforms such as the UK’s operational separation policy.

Suggested Citation

  • Holmes, Mark, 2026. "A Tale of Two Outcomes: Non-audit Services and Auditor Independence After the EU Audit Directive and Regulation (EU ADR)," CAFE Working Papers 41, Centre for Accountancy, Finance and Economics (CAFE), Birmingham City Business School, Birmingham City University.
  • Handle: RePEc:akf:cafewp:41
    as

    Download full text from publisher

    File URL: https://www.open-access.bcu.ac.uk/17238/1/Working_Paper_41.pdf
    Download Restriction: no
    ---><---

    References listed on IDEAS

    as
    1. Si Wen (Stacey) WANG & David HAY, 2013. "Auditor Independence in New Zealand: Further Evidence on the Role of Non-Audit Services," Accounting and Management Information Systems, Faculty of Accounting and Management Information Systems, The Bucharest University of Economic Studies, vol. 12(2), pages 235-262, June.
    2. Craswell, Allen & Stokes, Donald J. & Laughton, Janet, 2002. "Auditor independence and fee dependence," Journal of Accounting and Economics, Elsevier, vol. 33(2), pages 253-275, June.
    3. Antle, R, 1984. "Auditor Independence," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 22(1), pages 1-20.
    4. Michael Firth, 2002. "Auditor-Provided Consultancy Services and their Associations with Audit Fees and Audit Opinions," Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 29(5&6), pages 661-693.
    5. Gopal V. Krishnan & Wei Yu, 2011. "Further evidence on knowledge spillover and the joint determination of audit and non‐audit fees," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, vol. 26(3), pages 230-247, March.
    6. Rick Antle & Elizabeth Gordon & Ganapathi Narayanamoorthy & Ling Zhou, 2006. "The joint determination of audit fees, non-audit fees, and abnormal accruals," Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, Springer, vol. 27(3), pages 235-266, November.
    7. David F. Larcker & Scott A. Richardson, 2004. "Fees Paid to Audit Firms, Accrual Choices, and Corporate Governance," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 42(3), pages 625-658, June.
    8. Deborah Bloomfield & Joshua Shackman, 2008. "Non-audit service fees, auditor characteristics and earnings restatements," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing, vol. 23(2), pages 125-141, January.
    9. Dart, Eleanor, 2011. "UK investors’ perceptions of auditor independence," The British Accounting Review, Elsevier, vol. 43(3), pages 173-185.
    10. Beaulieu, Philip & Reinstein, Alan, 2010. "Belief perseverance among accounting practitioners regarding the effect of non-audit services on auditor independence," Journal of Accounting and Public Policy, Elsevier, vol. 29(4), pages 353-373, July.
    11. Sharad Asthana & Inder Khurana & K. K. Raman, 2019. "Fee competition among Big 4 auditors and audit quality," Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, Springer, vol. 52(2), pages 403-438, February.
    12. Singh, Abhijeet & Singh, Harjinder & Sultana, Nigar & Evans, John, 2019. "Independent and joint effects of audit partner tenure and non-audit fees on audit quality," Journal of Contemporary Accounting and Economics, Elsevier, vol. 15(2), pages 186-205.
    13. Jere R. Francis & Bin Ke, 2006. "Disclosure of fees paid to auditors and the market valuation of earnings surprises," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 11(4), pages 495-523, December.
    14. Owusu, Andrews & O’Sullivan, Noel & Kwabi, Frank & Holmes, Mark David, 2024. "Why do female lead auditors charge a fee premium? evidence from the UK audit market," Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, Elsevier, vol. 57(C).
    15. Shivaram Rajgopal & Suraj Srinivasan & Xin Zheng, 2021. "Measuring audit quality," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 26(2), pages 559-619, June.
    16. Clive S. Lennox, 1999. "Audit Quality and Auditor Size: An Evaluation of Reputation and Deep Pockets Hypotheses," Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 26(7&8), pages 779-805.
    17. Scott Whisenant & Srinivasan Sankaraguruswamy & K. Raghunandan, 2003. "Evidence on the Joint Determination of Audit and Non‐Audit Fees," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 41(4), pages 721-744, September.
    18. Michael Firth, 2002. "Auditor–Provided Consultancy Services and their Associations with Audit Fees and Audit Opinions," Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 29(5‐6), pages 661-693.
    19. Owusu, Andrews & O'Sullivan, Noel & Kwabi, Frank & Holmes, Mark, 2024. "Why Do Female Lead Auditors Charge a Fee Premium? Evidence from the UK Audit Market," CAFE Working Papers 26, Centre for Accountancy, Finance and Economics (CAFE), Birmingham City Business School, Birmingham City University.
    20. Xia Chen & Qiang Cheng & Xin Wang, 2015. "Does increased board independence reduce earnings management? Evidence from recent regulatory reforms," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 20(2), pages 899-933, June.
    21. Simunic, Da, 1984. "Auditing, Consulting, And Auditor Independence," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 22(2), pages 679-702.
    22. repec:eme:maj000:maj-06-2014-1045 is not listed on IDEAS
    23. Giuseppe Ianniello & Giuseppe Galloppo, 2015. "Stock market reaction to auditor opinions – Italian evidence," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, vol. 30(6/7), pages 610-632, July.
    24. Giuseppe Ianniello & Giuseppe Galloppo, 2015. "Stock market reaction to auditor opinions – Italian evidence," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing, vol. 30(6/7), pages 610-632, July.
    25. Domenico Campa & Ray Donnelly, 2016. "Non-audit services provided to audit clients, independence of mind and independence in appearance: latest evidence from large UK listed companies," Accounting and Business Research, Taylor & Francis Journals, vol. 46(4), pages 422-449, June.
    26. repec:eme:maj000:02686900810839839 is not listed on IDEAS
    27. David Castillo-Merino & Josep Garcia-Blandon & Monica Martinez-Blasco, 2020. "Auditor Independence, Current and Future NAS Fees and Audit Quality: Were European Regulators Right?," European Accounting Review, Taylor & Francis Journals, vol. 29(2), pages 233-262, March.
    28. Clive S. Lennox, 1999. "Audit Quality and Auditor Size: An Evaluation of Reputation and Deep Pockets Hypotheses," Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 26(7‐8), pages 779-805, September.
    29. Mark L. DeFond & K. Raghunandan & K.R. Subramanyam, 2002. "Do Non–Audit Service Fees Impair Auditor Independence? Evidence from Going Concern Audit Opinions," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 40(4), pages 1247-1274, September.
    30. Tong Lu, 2006. "Does Opinion Shopping Impair Auditor Independence and Audit Quality?," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 44(3), pages 561-583, June.
    31. Rick Antle & Elizabeth Gordon & Ganapathi Narayanamoorthy & Ling Zhou, 2002. "The Joint Determination of Audit Fees, Non-Audit Fees, and Abnormal Accruals," Yale School of Management Working Papers amz2502, Yale School of Management, revised 02 May 2006.
    32. Johnson, Marilyn F. & Nelson, Karen K. & Frankel, Richard M., 2002. "The Relation Between Auditor's Fees for Non-audit Services and Earnings Quality," Research Papers 1696r, Stanford University, Graduate School of Business.
    33. Deborah Bloomfield & Joshua Shackman, 2008. "Non‐audit service fees, auditor characteristics and earnings restatements," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing Limited, vol. 23(2), pages 125-141, January.
    34. Garcia-Blandon, Josep & Argiles, Josep Ma, 2015. "Audit firm tenure and independence: A comprehensive investigation of audit qualifications in Spain," Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, Elsevier, vol. 24(C), pages 82-93.
    35. William R. Kinney & Zoe‐Vonna Palmrose & Susan Scholz, 2004. "Auditor Independence, Non‐Audit Services, and Restatements: Was the U.S. Government Right?," Journal of Accounting Research, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd., vol. 42(3), pages 561-588, June.
    36. Rick Antle & Elizabeth Gordon & Ganapathi Narayanamoorthy & Ling Zhou, 2002. "The Joint Determination of Audit Fees, Non-Audit Fees, and Abnormal Accruals," Yale School of Management Working Papers amz2502, Yale School of Management, revised 02 May 2006.
    37. Gopal V. Krishnan & Wei Yu, 2011. "Further evidence on knowledge spillover and the joint determination of audit and non-audit fees," Managerial Auditing Journal, Emerald Group Publishing, vol. 26(3), pages 230-247, March.
    38. repec:eme:maj000:02686901111113181 is not listed on IDEAS
    Full references (including those not matched with items on IDEAS)

    Most related items

    These are the items that most often cite the same works as this one and are cited by the same works as this one.
    1. .Reiner Quick & Matthias Sattler, 2011. "Beeinträchtigen Beratungsleistungen die Urteilsfreiheit des Abschlussprüfers? Zum Einfluss von Beratungshonoraren auf diskretionäre Periodenabgrenzungen," Schmalenbach Journal of Business Research, Springer, vol. 63(4), pages 310-343, June.
    2. Yu (Elli) Zhang & David Hay & Claus Holm, 2016. "Non-audit services and auditor independence: Norwegian evidence," Cogent Business & Management, Taylor & Francis Journals, vol. 3(1), pages 1215223-121, December.
    3. Anastasia Kraft & Kerstin Lopatta, 2016. "Auditor fees, discretionary book-tax differences, and tax avoidance," International Journal of Economics and Accounting, Inderscience Enterprises Ltd, vol. 7(2), pages 127-155.
    4. Reshma Kumari Tiwari & Jasojit Debnath, 2021. "Joint Provision of Non-audit Services to Audit Clients: Empirical Evidences from India," Vikalpa: The Journal for Decision Makers, , vol. 46(3), pages 153-165, September.
    5. Daniela Hohenfels & Reiner Quick, 2020. "Non-audit services and audit quality: evidence from Germany," Review of Managerial Science, Springer, vol. 14(5), pages 959-1007, October.
    6. Kevin Koh & Shiva Rajgopal & Suraj Srinivasan, 2013. "Non-audit services and financial reporting quality: evidence from 1978 to 1980," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 18(1), pages 1-33, March.
    7. Bugeja, Martin, 2011. "Takeover premiums and the perception of auditor independence and reputation," The British Accounting Review, Elsevier, vol. 43(4), pages 278-293.
    8. Geiger, Marshall A. & Basioudis, Ilias G. & DeLange, Paul, 2022. "The effect of non-audit fees and industry specialization on the prevalence and accuracy of auditor’s going-concern reporting decisions," Journal of International Accounting, Auditing and Taxation, Elsevier, vol. 47(C).
    9. Garcia-Blandon, Josep & Argiles-Bosch, Josep Maria & Castillo-Merino, David & Martinez-Blasco, Monica, 2017. "An Assessment of the Provisions of Regulation (EU) No 537/2014 on Non-audit Services and Audit Firm Tenure: Evidence from Spain," The International Journal of Accounting, Elsevier, vol. 52(3), pages 251-261.
    10. Anandarajan, Asokan & Kleinman, Gary & Palmon, Dan, 2012. "Is non-audit services a suitable proxy for auditor independence in the post-SOX period?," Research in Accounting Regulation, Elsevier, vol. 24(2), pages 105-111.
    11. DeFond, Mark & Zhang, Jieying, 2014. "A review of archival auditing research," Journal of Accounting and Economics, Elsevier, vol. 58(2), pages 275-326.
    12. Domenico Campa & Ray Donnelly, 2016. "Non-audit services provided to audit clients, independence of mind and independence in appearance: latest evidence from large UK listed companies," Accounting and Business Research, Taylor & Francis Journals, vol. 46(4), pages 422-449, June.
    13. Jordan Schoenfeld, 2024. "Cyber risk and voluntary Service Organization Control (SOC) audits," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 29(1), pages 580-620, March.
    14. David Hay & Robert Knechel & Vivian Li, 2006. "Non‐audit Services and Auditor Independence: New Zealand Evidence," Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 33(5‐6), pages 715-734, June.
    15. Knechel, W. Robert & Thomas, Edward & Driskill, Matthew, 2020. "Understanding financial auditing from a service perspective," Accounting, Organizations and Society, Elsevier, vol. 81(C).
    16. Vieru, Markku & Schadewitz, Hannu, 2010. "Impact of IFRS transition on audit and non-audit fees: evidence from small and medium-sized listed companies in Finland," MPRA Paper 44664, University Library of Munich, Germany.
    17. Christopher Bleibtreu & Ulrike Stefani, 2024. "The interdependence between market structure and the quality of audited reports: the case of non-audit services," Review of Accounting Studies, Springer, vol. 29(2), pages 1524-1574, June.
    18. Tobias Svanstr�m, 2013. "Non-audit Services and Audit Quality: Evidence from Private Firms," European Accounting Review, Taylor & Francis Journals, vol. 22(2), pages 337-366, June.
    19. Ho, Nam, 2023. "Local competition and auditors' provision of non-audit services," Advances in accounting, Elsevier, vol. 63(C).
    20. Steven Cahan & David Emanuel & David Hay & Norman Wong, 2008. "Non‐audit fees, long‐term auditor–client relationships and earnings management," Accounting and Finance, Accounting and Finance Association of Australia and New Zealand, vol. 48(2), pages 181-207, June.

    More about this item

    NEP fields

    This paper has been announced in the following NEP Reports:

    Statistics

    Access and download statistics

    Corrections

    All material on this site has been provided by the respective publishers and authors. You can help correct errors and omissions. When requesting a correction, please mention this item's handle: RePEc:akf:cafewp:41. See general information about how to correct material in RePEc.

    If you have authored this item and are not yet registered with RePEc, we encourage you to do it here. This allows to link your profile to this item. It also allows you to accept potential citations to this item that we are uncertain about.

    If CitEc recognized a bibliographic reference but did not link an item in RePEc to it, you can help with this form .

    If you know of missing items citing this one, you can help us creating those links by adding the relevant references in the same way as above, for each refering item. If you are a registered author of this item, you may also want to check the "citations" tab in your RePEc Author Service profile, as there may be some citations waiting for confirmation.

    For technical questions regarding this item, or to correct its authors, title, abstract, bibliographic or download information, contact: Research Publications Librarian (email available below). General contact details of provider: https://edirc.repec.org/data/bsuceuk.html .

    Please note that corrections may take a couple of weeks to filter through the various RePEc services.

    IDEAS is a RePEc service. RePEc uses bibliographic data supplied by the respective publishers.