Combining the dynamic model and deep neural networks to identify the intensity of interventions during COVID-19 pandemic

During the COVID-19 pandemic, control measures, especially massive contact tracing following prompt quarantine and isolation, play an important role in mitigating the disease spread, and quantifying the dynamic contact rate and quarantine rate and estimate their impacts remain challenging. To precisely quantify the intensity of interventions, we develop the mechanism of physics-informed neural network (PINN) to propose the extended transmission-dynamics-informed neural network (TDINN) algorithm by combining scattered observational data with deep learning and epidemic models. The TDINN algorithm can not only avoid assuming the specific rate functions in advance but also make neural networks follow the rules of epidemic systems in the process of learning. We show that the proposed algorithm can fit the multi-source epidemic data in Xi’an, Guangzhou and Yangzhou cities well, and moreover reconstruct the epidemic development trend in Hainan and Xinjiang with incomplete reported data. We inferred the temporal evolution patterns of contact/quarantine rates, selected the best combination from the family of functions to accurately simulate the contact/quarantine time series learned by TDINN algorithm, and consequently reconstructed the epidemic process. The selected rate functions based on the time series inferred by deep learning have epidemiologically reasonable meanings. In addition, the proposed TDINN algorithm has also been verified by COVID-19 epidemic data with multiple waves in Liaoning province and shows good performance. We find the significant fluctuations in estimated contact/quarantine rates, and a feedback loop between the strengthening/relaxation of intervention strategies and the recurrence of the outbreaks. Moreover, the findings show that there is diversity in the shape of the temporal evolution curves of the inferred contact/quarantine rates in the considered regions, which indicates variation in the intensity of control strategies adopted in various regions.Author summary: When applying the compartment model to simulate the disease transmission dynamics, some parameters or particular functions are assumed to describe the intensity of the control interventions. However, these preset specific functions may not accurately quantify the intervention strategies, which brings great challenges to accurately make prediction and evaluation. In this study, we developed an extended transmission-dynamics-informed neural network algorithm by integrating deep neural network with epidemic model. Even for insufficient case data, the proposed algorithm can still help us reconstruct the temporal evolution trend of the epidemic and infer unknown parameters. We inferred the time series on contract rate and quarantine rate for six regions based on the case data, on which the reasonable and interpretable functions, describing the dynamic variation in the intensity of control strategies, can be successfully selected and determined. The inferred contact/quarantine rates in various regions show the diverse shapes and regional dependent, and hence the variation in the intensity of control measures. This suggests the dynamic zero-case policy exhibits the different efficacy in reducing contacts and increasing the quarantine and isolation.