Water Scarcity Footprint and Economic Feasibility of Precision Irrigation in Short Rotation Coppice for Energy in Italy

Effective water resource management in agriculture is a pivotal challenge for environmental sustainability and the economic viability of crop production. The present study, conducted at the CREA research station (Monterotondo, Italy), analyzed a precision irrigation strategy based on an automated drip irrigation system with soil moisture sensors, applied to a 15-year-old high-density poplar plantation for energy production. Five treatments were compared: a non-irrigated control (T0) and four irrigation levels based on soil moisture thresholds (T1 ≤ 20%, T2 ≤ 30%, T3 ≤ 40%, T4 ≤ 50%). The aim of this study was to assess the economic feasibility of irrigated poplar plantations, considering expected increases in biomass production and related environmental impacts. The economic evaluation used the Life Cycle Costing (LCC) method, while the environmental assessment applied Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) with the AWARE indicator to quantify the water scarcity footprint. Finally, an integrated assessment using the TOPSIS multi-criteria method was performed to identify the most sustainable treatment. Over the 15-year period, T0 (no irrigation) was the preferred option (Preferred Index Pi = 1.000), followed by T3 (Pi = 0.637) and T4 (Pi = 0.586), considering equal weighting of economic and environmental impacts. Conversely, the low irrigation treatment (T1) was the least sustainable (Pi = 0.379), followed by T2 (Pi = 0.486). While irrigation appears unviable if environmental impacts are prioritized, higher biomass value can improve the economic sustainability of treatments with greater water use (T3 and T4) when economic factors dominate.