Sustainable Performance-Cost-GWP Pareto Optimization of RAP-Modified High-Performance Asphalt Pavements: An Alberta Design Case Study

Road construction contributes to embodied carbon in infrastructure, with asphalt-bound layers often dominating construction-stage greenhouse gas emissions in flexible pavements. Reclaimed asphalt pavement (RAP) and high-modulus asphalt concrete can reduce virgin material demand and improve structural efficiency, but their sustainability benefit depends on maintaining equivalent pavement performance. This study develops a climate-informed, mechanistic, environmental, and economic Pareto optimization framework for RAP-modified high-performance asphalt concrete (RAP-HPAC) pavement sections in Alberta. The framework couples fitted dynamic modulus master curves, monthly pavement temperature inputs, ALVA layered elastic analysis, Asphalt Institute fatigue and rutting criteria, A1–A5 global warming potential (GWP), and Alberta 2026 installed unit-price cost data. The RAP-HPAC mixture contains 50% RAP and was designed through a balanced mix design to target approximately 80% effective RAP binder activation. Three traffic classes were evaluated: 731, 1300, and 5426 ESAL/day/direction, each with 2% annual compound growth over a 20-year design period. Relative to independently optimized conventional HMA controls, Pareto-selected RAP-HPAC sections reduced P50 construction-stage GWP by approximately 19–30% and first cost by approximately 6–11% at a conservative 0.90× RAP-HPAC cost multiplier. The results show that RAP-HPAC is most beneficial when used as a structural-bound base that replaces conventional asphalt-bound capacity while preserving sufficient granular support. The framework provides a reproducible design-stage approach for comparing recycled high-modulus asphalt mixtures using performance, carbon, and cost criteria simultaneously.