Collaborative and Coordinated Distribution Under Infrastructure Constraints in Smallholder Cocoa Producer Networks

Agricultural supply chains operating under rural infrastructure constraints face persistent logistical inefficiencies that reduce producer income and weaken territorial sustainability. This paper assesses how collaborative and coordinated distribution architectures reshape economic performance, efficiency, and equity in dispersed networks of cocoa producers in El Carmen de Bolívar, Colombia. The unified optimization framework compares three regimes: decentralized non-collaborative individual shipments, collaborative consolidation based on distribution centers, and coordinated distribution with time-window synchronization. The findings show a reduction in average logistics costs from $0.688/kg in decentralized distribution to $0.323/kg with collaborative distribution centers, and even further to $0.282/kg in coordinated distribution, representing an overall reduction of approximately 59%. A sensitivity analysis across 64 accessibility configurations shows that the advantage of coordination increases as time rigidity increases. These structural improvements translate into a 13.97% increase in total producer utility, raising average utility from $278 to $317 per producer. In addition, the distributional assessment based on Lorenz curves and Gini coefficients indicates that inequality remains stable despite gains in welfare. These results demonstrate that spatial consolidation combined with temporal synchronization is a decisive lever for resilient and inclusive rural supply systems.