Comparative Assessment of Residential Heating and Ventilation Packages: Operational Energy Performance and Screening Life-Cycle Carbon Context

The environmental performance of residential buildings depends not only on envelope quality but also on the choice of heating, domestic hot water, and ventilation systems. This study presents a comparative assessment of eight technology packages for a reference single-family house located in Warsaw, Poland, using a harmonised framework under Polish EPC calculation assumptions, with identical building parameters, system boundaries, and functional assumptions for all variants. Operational performance was evaluated using Energy Performance Certificate indicators, including useful energy, final energy, non-renewable primary energy, operational CO 2 emissions, and the share of renewable energy sources. In addition, a comparative 50-year scenario of operational CO 2 emissions was developed, and a screening life-cycle carbon assessment of the reference building fabric and major building components was performed to provide a material and construction-related carbon context for the operational comparison. The embodied impacts of package-specific technical systems were excluded from the LCA scope. The results showed that fossil-dominated packages generated the highest primary energy demand and operational emissions, whereas renewable-supported and hybrid configurations substantially improved environmental performance. Under the adopted EPC-based accounting assumptions, the fully renewable packages achieved the lowest operational indicators; however, these variants should be interpreted as upper-bound theoretical scenarios rather than as demonstrated real-life zero-emission solutions. Therefore, they were not used as the main basis for the practical ranking. Among the practically comparable mixed configurations, the most favourable operational results were obtained for renewable-supported heat-pump-based packages. The screening life-cycle assessment indicated that a substantial part of the total environmental burden was associated with the product and construction stages of the reference building. The results confirm that the interpretation of residential technical packages depends strongly on the adopted assessment perspective and that operational indicators should be considered together with at least a screening-level carbon context for the building fabric. According to the calculation results, the EP value ranges from 0 to 90.8 kWh/(m 2 ·year), depending on the technology package.