Variations in Sleep, Fatigue, and Difficulty with Concentration Among Emergency Medical Services Clinicians During Shifts of Different Durations

We sought to characterize momentary changes in fatigue, sleepiness, and difficulty with concentration during short and long duration shifts worked by emergency medical services (EMS) and fire personnel across the United States. In addition, we tested for differences in pre-shift and on-shift sleep stratified by shift duration. We examined real-time mobile-phone text message queries during scheduled shifts from the EMS Sleep Health Study, a nationwide, cluster-randomized trial (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04218279). Linear mixed effects models were used and Bonferroni p -values reported for multiple comparisons. In total, 388 EMS clinicians from 35 EMS/fire agencies documented 4573 shifts and responded to 64.6% of 161,888 text message queries. Most shifts (85.5%) were 12 or 24 h in duration. Mean sleep hours pre-shift was 6.2 (SD1.9) and mean sleep hours on shift was 3.4 (SD2.9) and varied by shift duration ( p < 0.0001). The highest level of fatigue, sleepiness, and difficulty with concentration during any shift occurred during 24 h shifts and corresponded to the early morning hours at 03:00 or 04:00 a.m. The real-time assessments of sleep hours and fatigue in this study revealed deficits in sleep health for EMS and fire personnel and critical time points for intervention during shifts when the risk to safety is high.