Shadows of Demand: Uncovering Early Warning Signals of Private Consumption Declines in Romania

Policymakers in small open economies need reliable signals of incipient private consumption downturns, yet traditional indicators are revised, noisy, and often arrive too late. This study develops a Romanian-specific early warning system that combines a time-varying parameter VAR with stochastic volatility and exogenous drivers (TVP-SV-VARX) with modern machine learning classifiers. The structural layer extracts regime-dependent anomalies in the macro-financial transmission to household demand, while the learning layer transforms these anomalies into calibrated probabilities of short-term consumption declines. A strictly time-based evaluation design with rolling blocks, purge and embargo periods, and rare-event metrics (precision–recall area under the curve, PR-AUC, and Brier score) underpins the assessment. The best-performing specification, a TVP-filtered random forest, attains a PR-AUC of 0.87, a ROC-AUC of 0.89, a median warning lead of one quarter, and no false positives at the chosen operating point. A sparse logistic calibration model improves probability reliability and supports transparent communication of risk bands. The time-varying anomaly layer is critical: ablation experiments that remove it lead to marked losses in discrimination and recall. For implementation, the paper proposes a three-tier WATCH–AMBER–RED scheme with conservative multi-signal confirmation and coverage gates, designed to balance lead time against the political cost of false alarms. The framework is explicitly predictive rather than causal and is tailored to data-poor environments, offering a practical blueprint for demand-side macroeconomic early warning in Romania and, by extension, other small open economies.