Stationary probabilities and the monotone likelihood ratio in bonus-malus systems

The bonus-malus system (BMS) is a widely recognized and commonly employed risk management tool. A well-designed BMS can match expected insurance payments with estimated claims even in a diverse group of risks. Although there has been abundant research on improving bonus-malus (BM) systems, one important aspect has been overlooked: the stationary probability of a BMS satisfies the monotone likelihood ratio property. The monotone likelihood ratio for stationary probabilities allows us to better understand how riskier policyholders are more likely to remain in higher premium categories, while less risky policyholders are more likely to move toward lower premiums. This study establishes this property for BMSs that are described by an ergodic Markov chain with one possible claim and a transition rule +1/-d. We derive this result from the linear recurrences that characterize the stationary distribution; this represents a novel analytical approach in this domain. We also illustrate the practical implications of our findings: in the BM design problem, the premium scale is automatically monotonic.