Conditional expectations given the sum of independent random variables with regularly varying densities

The conditional expectation $m_{X}(s)=\mathrm{E}[X|S=s]$ , where X and Y are two independent random variables with $S=X+Y$ , plays a key role in various actuarial applications. For instance, considering the conditional mean risk-sharing rule, $m_X(s)$ determines the contribution of the agent holding the risk X to a risk-sharing pool. It is also a relevant function in the context of risk management, for example, when considering natural capital allocation principles. The monotonicity of $m_X(\!\cdot\!)$ is particularly significant under these frameworks, and it has been linked to log-concave densities since Efron (1965). However, the log-concavity assumption may not be realistic in some applications because it excludes heavy-tailed distributions. We consider random variables with regularly varying densities to illustrate how heavy tails can lead to a nonmonotonic behavior for $m_X(\!\cdot\!)$ . This paper first aims to identify situations where $m_X(\!\cdot\!)$ could fail to be increasing according to the tail heaviness of X and Y. Second, the paper aims to study the asymptotic behavior of $m_X(s)$ as the value s of the sum gets large. The analysis is then extended to zero-augmented probability distributions, commonly encountered in applications to insurance, and to sums of more than two random variables and to two random variables with a Farlie–Gumbel–Morgenstern copula. Consequences for risk sharing and capital allocation are discussed. Many numerical examples illustrate the results.