Between Presumption and Despair: Augustine's Hope for the Commonwealth

Many political theorists dismiss Augustine as a pessimist about politics, assuming his “otherworldly†account of love precludes hope for this-worldly politics. This article challenges this pessimism by applying recent research on Augustine's “order of love†to reconstruct his implicit order of hope. Analyzing neglected sermons, letters, and treatises, I argue that Augustine encourages hope for temporal goods as long as that hope is rightly ordered and avoids the corresponding vices of presumption and despair. I then identify “civic peace†as a common object of hope that diverse citizens can share. By recovering hope as a virtue and reframing civic peace as a positive form of civic friendship, I argue that Augustine commends a hope for the commonwealth that avoids both presumption and despair. I conclude by analyzing how Augustine's vision of the commonwealth can inform contemporary political theory and practice.