An off-peak energy storage concept for electric utilities: Part I--Electric utility requirements

The water battery, a reversible water electrolyser device being developed in a long-term research effort at Battelle's Columbus Laboratories, was evaluated in an analytical and conceptual design study as a load-levelling system for an electric utility. During periods when off-peak electrical power was available, the water battery would produce hydrogen and oxygen by electrolysis of water; during peak demand periods the water battery would be operated in the reverse mode, functioning as a fuel cell by producing electrical power through the recombination of the oxygen and hydrogen held in its storage vessels. The analysis involved characterisation of the PSE&G system demand requirements now and in the future, its current off-peak energy availability, the typical sizing and placement of energy storage units and the approximate break even economics and potential advantages to the utility of a water battery energy storage system. In the economic analysis, the water battery was compared with the gas turbine and the fuel cell for cost effectiveness in meeting peak and intermediate power demands, respectively. Compared with a [`]reformer-type' fuel cell (costed at $300/kW for intermediate duty) the break even capital cost of a 50% efficient water battery would be $100/kW plus about $200/kW for each increase of $1/106 Btu above the reference cost of $1/106 Btu for fossil fuel. The available margin would increase about $50/kW for each decrease of 1 mill/kWh in off-peak energy cost below the reference cost of 8 mills/kWh. In a similar comparison with the gas turbine (costed at $135/kW) for peaking duty, the break even cost of a 50% efficient water battery would be $100/kW. The break even cost could rise about $100/kW for each increase in fossil fuel cost of $1/106 Btu and about $20/kW for each decrease in off-peak energy cost of 1 mill/kWh.