Tableau Économique and Quesnay's Views on Wealth Power: An Inquiry into Consistency

Loïc Charles and Philippe Steiner (2000) rightly draw our attention to Quesnay's neglected political views, namely the project of making France strong enough to confront England in economic and in military affairs. Schematically, Quesnay insists more upon wealth than upon population, which makes for a difference with most of the economists of his time, and more upon the navy than upon the army. Walter Eltis (1999) carefully relates the “explanations†of the Tableau économique contained in l'Ami des Hommes and the Philosophie rurale to the policy recommendations of Quesnay. He emphasizes the practical character of these different Tableaux in contrast with the abstract character of the first versions and of the Formule. He also gives a detailed account of the efects of diferent policies, namely the extension of grande culture, free trade of corn (which amounts to a higher price of corn), and tax reform. Gianni Vaggi (2001) insists on the modernization of agriculture as a decisive element of the power of a nation. Such preoccupations seem well in accordance with Quesnay's more general concern—that is, refounding the French monarchy on a natural order in which politics and economics can hardly be distinguished.