The Intention of the Framers: A Note on Constitutional Interpretation

In discussions of the United States Constitution, the phrase “the intention of the framers†is often used, but it is hardly ever adequately analyzed. The search for the intentions of the framers is made obviously in the hope of finding out what they meant by the words they put into the written Constitution. This leads to the examination of various evidences outside the Constitution, and implies a feeling that there is a lack of clarity in the words of that document.The discussion that follows was written in order, first, to raise some of the questions that I think have to be answered before the phrase about intentions can have fullness of meaning as a tool of constitutional analysis; second, to express certain warnings against a too-confident assumption that “the intention of the framers†can actually be known; and, third, to consider briefly the possible significance today of the intention of the framers in case it could be discovered.