NFL results with soccer scoring

Americans typically complain that soccer is too low scoring. The issue is that only goals are counted in soccer, not corner kicks, free kicks, or anything else. This page does to the NFL what soccer does to its scoring: count only touchdowns.

The first score is the official NFL score, the second is the one I count "soccer style". A ranking is at the end. In bold are games where the winner is not identical for both scoring conventions. Note that for soccer style scoring, I do not count overtime, even if the game was tied in touchdowns. Indeed, there are plenty of ties in soccer style scoring that did not get the opportunity to go into overtime.

Interestingly, the playoff picture would look quite different, especially for the wild cards. One would have suspected that any differing results between the two systems would even out over a season. But evidently, some teams are better at touchdowns, others at field goals.

Standings
Playoffs
Score distribution


Week 1, September 7, 10, 11, 2006

Miami-Pittsburgh17-28 2-3
Atlanta-Carolina 20-6 2-0
Baltimore-Tampa Bay 27-0 3-0
Buffalo-New England17-192-2
Cincinnati-Kansas City 23-10 2-1
Denver-St. Louis10-181-0
New Orleans-Cleveland19-141-2
NY Jets-Tennessee 23-16 3-2
Philadelphia-Houston 24-10 3-1
Seattle-Detroit9-60-0
Chicago-Green Bay 26-0 2-0
Dallas-Jacksonville 17-24 2-3
San Francisco-Arizona 27-34 3-4
Indianapolis-NY Giants26-212-3
Minnesota-Washington 19-16 2-1
San Diego-Oakland 27-0 3-0

Week 2, September 17, 18, 2006

Buffalo-Miami16-61-0
Carolina-Minnesota13-16 (OT)1-1
Cleveland-Cincinnati17-342-4
Detroit-Chicago7-341-4
Houston-Indianapolis24-433-5
New Orleans-Green Bay34-274-3
NY Giants-Philadelphia30-24 (OT)3-3
Oakland-Baltimore6-280-2
Tampa Bay-Atlanta3-140-2
Arizona-Seattle10-211-3
St. Louis-San Francisco13-201-2
Kansas City-Denver6-90-0
New England-NY Jets24-173-2
Tennessee-San Diego7-401-4
Washington-Dallas10-271-3
Pittsburgh-Jacksonville0-90-0

Week 3, September 24, 25, 2006

Carolina-Tampa Bay26-242-3
Chicago-Minnesota19-161-1
Cincinnati-Pittsburgh28-204-2
Green Bay-Detroit31-244-3
Jacksonville-Indianapolis14-212-3
NY Jets-Buffalo28-204-2
Tennessee-Miami10-131-1
Washington-Houston31-154-2
Baltimore-Cleveland15-141-2
NY Giants-Seattle30-424-6
Philadelphia-San Francisco38-245-3
St. Louis-Arizona16-141-2
Denver-New England17-72-1
Atlanta-New Orleans3-230-2

Week 4, October 1, 2, 2006

Arizona-Atlanta10-321-2
Dallas-Tennessee45-146-1
Indianapolis-NY Jets31-284-4
Miami-Houston15-171-2
Minnesota-Buffalo12-171-2
New Orleans-Carolina18-212-3
San Diego-Baltimore13-161-2
San Francisco-Kansas City0-410-5
Detroit-St. Louis34-414-4
Cleveland-Oakland24-213-3
Jacksonville-Washington30-36 (OT)3-3
New England-Cincinnati38-135-1
Seattle-Chicago6-370-4
Green Bay-Philadelphia9-310-4

Week 5, October 8, 9, 2006

Buffalo-Chicago7-401-4
Cleveland-Carolina12-200-2
Detroit-Minnesota17-262-3
Miami-New England10-201-2
St. Louis-Green Bay23-202-2
Tampa Bay-New Orleans21-243-3
Tennessee-Indianapolis13-141-2
Washington-NY Giants3-190-1
Kansas City-Arizona23-202-2
NY Jets-Jacksonville0-410-5
Oakland-San Francisco20-342-4
Dallas-Philadelphia24-383-5
Pittsburgh-San Diego13-231-2
Baltimore-Denver3-130-1

Week 6, October 15, 16, 2006

Buffalo-Detroit17-102-2
Carolina-Baltimore23-212-3
Cincinnati-Tampa Bay13-141-2
Houston-Dallas6-340-4
NY Giants-Atlanta27-143-2
Philadelphia-New Orleans24-273-3
Seattle-St. Louis30-283-4
Tennessee-Washington25-222-3
Kansas City-Pittsburgh7-451-5
Miami-NY Jets17-202-2
San Diego-San Francisco48-196-2
Oakland-Denver3-130-1
Chicago-Arizona24-233-2

Week 7, October 22, 23, 2006

Carolina-Cincinnati14-172-2
Detroit-NY Jets24-313-4
Green Bay-Miami34-244-2
Jacksonville-Houston7-271-3
New England-Buffalo28-64-0
Philadelphia-Tampa Bay21-233-2
Pittsburgh-Atlanta38-415-5
San Diego-Kansas City27-303-4
Denver-Cleveland17-72-1
Arizona-Oakland9-220-2
Minnesota-Seattle31-134-1
Washington-Indianapolis22-363-4
NY Giants-Dallas36-224-3

Week 8, October 29, 30, 2006

Arizona-Green Bay14-312-4
Atlanta-Cincinnati29-273-3
Baltimore-New Orleans35-225-3
Houston-Tennessee22-283-4
Jacksonville-Philadelphia13-61-0
Seattle-Kansas City28-354-4
San Francisco-Chicago10-411-5
Tamba Bay-NY Giants3-170-2
St. Louis-San Diego24-383-5
Indianapolis-Denver34-313-4
NY Jets-Cleveland13-201-2
Pittsburgh-Oakland13-201-2
Dallas-Carolina35-144-2
New England-Minnesota31-74-1

Week 9, November 5,6, 2006

Atlanta-Detroit14-302-3
Cincinnati-Baltimore20-262-2
Dallas-Washington19-222-2
Green Bay-Buffalo10-241-3
Houston-NY Giants10-141-2
Kansas City-St. Louis31-174-2
Miami-Chicago31-134-2
New Orleans-Tampa Bay31-144-2
Tennessee-Jacksonville7-371-4
Minnesota-San Francisco3-90-0
Cleveland-San Diego25-321-4
Denver-Pittsburgh31-204-2
Indianapolis-New England27-203-2
Oakland-Seattle0-160-1

Week 10, November 12,13, 2006

Baltimore-Tennesse27-263-3
Buffalo-Indianapolis16-171-2
Cleveland-Atlanta17-132-1
Green Bay-Minnesota23-172-2
Houston-Jacksonville13-101-1
Kansas City-Miami10-131-1
NY Jets-New England17-142-1
San Diego-Cincinnati49-417-5
San Francisco-Detroit19-131-1
Washington-Philadelphia3-270-3
Denver-Oakland17-132-1
New Orleans-Pittsburgh31-384-5
Dallas-Arizona27-103-1
St. Louis-Seattle22-242-3
Chicago-NY Giants38-205-2
Tampa Bay-Carolina10-241-3

Week 11, November 19, 20, 2006

Atlanta-Baltimore10-241-3
Buffalo-Houston24-213-3
Chicago-NY Jets10-01-0
Cincinnati-New Orleans31-164-2
Minnesota-Miami20-242-3
New England-Green Bay35-05-0
Oakland-Kansas City13-171-2
Pittsburgh-Cleveland24-203-2
St. Louis-Carolina0-150-1
Tennessee-Philadelphia31-133-1
Washington-Tampa Bay17-202-2
Detroit-Arizona10-171-2
Seattle-San Francisco14-202-2
Indianapolis-Dallas14-212-3
San Diego-Denver35-275-3
NY Giants-Jacksonville10-261-2

Week 12, November 23, 26, 27, 2006

Miami-Detroit27-103-1
Dallas-Tampa Bay10-381-5
Denver-Kansas City10-191-1
Arizona-Minnesota26-313-4
Carolina-Washington13-171-2
Cincinnati-Cleveland30-04-0
Houston-NY Jets11-261-2
Jacksonville-Buffalo24-273-3
New Orleans-Atlanta31-134-1
Pittsburgh-Baltimore0-270-3
San Francisco-St. Louis17-202-2
Oakland-San Diego14-212-3
Chicago-New England13-171-2
NY Giants-Tennessee21-243-3
Philadelphia-Indianapolis21-453-6
Green Bay-Seattle24-343-3

Week 13, November 30, December 3, 4, 2006

Baltimore-Cincinnati7-131-1
Arizona-St. Louis34-204-2
Atlanta-Washington24-143-2
Detroit-New England21-281-3
Indianapolis-Tennessee17-202-2
Kansas City-Cleveland28-31 (OT)4-4
Minnesota-Chicago13-231-3
NY Jets-Green Bay38-105-1
San Diego-Buffalo24-213-3
San Francisco-New Orleans10-341-3
Jacksonville-Miami24-103-1
Houston-Oakland23-142-2
Dallas-NY Giants23-202-2
Tampa Bay-Pittsburgh3-200-2
Seattle-Denver23-202-2
Carolina-Philadelphia24-273-3

Week 14, December 7, 10, 11, 2006

Cleveland-Pittsburgh7-271-3
Atlanta-Tampa Bay17-62-0
Baltimore-Kansas City20-102-1
Indianapolis-Jacksonville17-442-5
Minnesota-Detroit30-204-1
New England-Miami0-210-2
NY Giants-Carolina27-133-1
Oakland-Cincinnati10-271-4
Philadelphia-Washington21-193-1
Tennessee-Houston26-20 (OT)2-2
Green Bay-San Francisco30-193-2
Seattle-Arizona21-273-3
Buffalo-NY Jets31-134-1
Denver-San Diego20-486-2
New Orleans-Dallas42-176-2
Chicago-St. Louis42-276-4

Week 15, December 14, 16, 17, 18, 2006

San Francisco-Seattle24-143-2
Dallas-Atlanta38-285-4
Cleveland-Baltimore17-272-3
Detroit-Green Bay9-170-2
Houston-New England7-401-4
Jacksonville-Tennessee17-242-3
Miami-Buffalo0-210-3
NY Jets-Minnesota26-132-2
Pittsburgh-Carolina37-34-0
Chicago-Tampa Bay34-31 (OT)4-4
Washington-New Orleans16-101-1
Denver-Arizona37-204-2
Philadelphia-NY Giants36-225-2
St. Louis-Oakland20-02-0
Kansas City-San Diego9-200-2
Cincinnati-Indianapolis16-341-4

Week 16, December 21, 23, 24, 25, 2006

Minnesota-Green Bay7-91-0
Kansas City-St. Louis20-92-0
Baltimore-Pittsburgh31-74-1
Carolina-Atlanta10-31-0
Chicago-Detroit26-212-3
Indianapolis-Houston24-273-3
New England-Jacksonville24-213-3
New Orleans-NY Giants30-74-1
Tampa Bay-Cleveland22-72-1
Tennesse-Buffalo30-293-2
Washington-St. Louis31-37 (OT)4-4
Arizona-San Francisco26-202-2
Cincinnati-Denver23-243-3
San Diego-Seattle20-172-2
Philadephia-Dallas23-72-1
NY Jets-Miami13-101-1

Week 17, December 30, 31, 2006

NY Giants-Washington34-283-3
Carolina-New Orleans31-214-3
Cleveland-Houston6-140-2
Detroit-Dallas39-314-4
Jacksonville-Kansas City30-354-5
New England-Tennessee40-235-2
Oakland-NY Jets3-230-2
Pittsburgh-Cincinnati23-17 (OT)2-2
Seattle-Tampa Bay23-72-1
St. Louis-Minnesota41-215-3
Atlanta-Philadelphia17-242-3
Buffalo-Baltimore7-191-1
Miami-Indianapolis22-271-3
Arizona-San Diego20-272-3
San Francisco-Denver26-23 (OT)2-2
Green Bay-Chicago26-73-1

Standings

2 points for a win, 1 point for a tie, none for a loss. Tie breakers for those with equal points: fewer games played, then TD difference, then TD+.

AFC

EastWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
New England104246222224
NY Jets75435341820
Buffalo55633351614
Miami48425311212
NorthWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
Baltimore102438212224
Cincinnati64643391816
Pittsburgh76339341716
Cleveland41022540108
SouthWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
Indianapolis94350412124
Jacksonville74542341916
Tennessee47534461316
Houston39530411112
WestWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
San Diego122259322628
Denver92636312418
Kansas City64637331818
Oakland2112163264

NFC

EastWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
Philadelphia103349342320
Dallas85352401918
NY Giants75439421816
Washington37632391210
NorthWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
Chicago104248292226
Minnesota65532311712
Green Bay67332411516
Detroit295304496
SouthWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
New Orleans76349401720
Carolina67328331516
Atlanta59232371214
Tampa Bay3103234198
WestWLTTD+TD-Pts.NFL Pts
Seattle53634331618
San Francisco37630451214
Arizona49333421110
St. Louis310437481016

Qualified for playoffs

According to NFL rulesWith soccer-style scoring
Conference ChampionsSan Diego
Chicago
San Diego
Philadelphia
Division ChampionsNew England, Baltimore, Indianapolis
Philadelphia, New Orleans, Seattle
New England, Baltimore, Indianapolis
Chicago, New Orleans, Seattle
Wild CardsNY Jets, Kansas City
Dallas, NY Giants
Denver, Jacksonville
Dallas, NY Giants

Score distribution

(in parentheses, score distribution for MLS 2006 regular season)
0-0: 4 (14)
1-0: 11 (49)
1-1: 11 (34)
2-0: 17 (9)
2-1: 33 (32)
2-2: 21 (5)
3-0: 5 (6)
3-1: 19 (10)
3-2: 29 (13)
3-3: 18 (5)
4-0: 6 (3)
4-1: 15 (3)
4-2: 15
4-3: 12 (2)
4-4: 7
5-0: 3
5-1: 5 (1)
5-2: 4 (3)
5-3: 7
5-4: 3 (1)
5-5: 1
6-0: (1)
6-1: 1
6-2: 3
6-3: 1
6-4: 2
7-5: 1
Contact

© Copyright 2007 Christian Zimmermann
All rights reserved
URL: http://ideas.repec.org/zimm/experimental/nfl2006final.html